top of page

PROTEUS: One Athlete, Many Capabilities

Writer: Aidan Malody
Aidan Malody
5 days ago
10 min read

Another cycle down, which means another one is right around the corner.

I was talking to a member a few weeks back about how I'm potentially both the most excited and most curious I've been about an upcoming cycle. Not because I think I've created some revolutionary new training program, or because I'm worried that what we're about to do won't work. But because, from an intention and programming standpoint, this one is going to be a little different.

We're calling it PROTEUS.

Before I get into what that means, a little context.


A Brief History Lesson Nobody Asked For

A while back, I came across a clip from a CrossFit seminar, most likely a Level 1 or 2, where one of the redshirts (seminar staff) was explaining why CrossFit doesn't traditionally program in cycles. And when he says CrossFit, he's referring specifically to CrossFit.com, or what most of us call dot com.

Since the beginning, CrossFit.com has posted a workout of the day, following a three-days-on, one-day-off, two-days-on, one-day-off schedule. Sometimes it's a heavy lift. Sometimes it's a short, aggressive conditioning workout. Sometimes it's a longer endurance piece. Sometimes it's rest.

For example, look at what dot com programmed November 14–16:

Saturday, November 14

12-minute AMRAP:

  • 15/20-calorie Echo bike

  • 5 muscle-ups

Sunday, November 15

Rest day.

Monday, November 16

5 rounds:

  • 3 rope climbs (15 feet)

  • Max set of bodyweight bench presses

  • Rest 3 minutes between rounds

That's it. Three days, two very different training sessions, and a rest day. No additional strength piece, no accessory finisher, and no obligatory metcon because someone felt the workout needed more stuff.

His reasoning wasn't that training cycles are bad. It was that CrossFit, as a methodology, is centered around GPP. General physical preparedness.

The goal is to develop fitness across a broad range of movements, loads, skills, energy systems, and time domains. Not necessarily to become exceptional at one thing, but to become increasingly capable at a whole lot of things.

His argument was that when we dedicate a significant amount of time and energy to improving a handful of qualities, we can unintentionally neglect others.

He used Olympic weightlifting as an example. The snatch and clean and jerk require coordination, timing, mobility, strength, speed, and a whole lot of practice. For most people, these aren't movements you can disappear from for two months and expect to magically improve.

There's an old CrossFit line that sums this up pretty well:

"We fail at the margins of our experience."

Essentially, the things we don't regularly expose ourselves to tend to be the things we're least prepared for.

I remember hearing that argument and thinking, "Yeah, that makes sense." But I also believe pretty strongly in the benefits of focused training cycles.

So where's the balance? And more importantly, are you down with GPP? Feels like CrossFit missed a pretty obvious marketing opportunity with Naughty by Nature.


Well, That Depends

There's a reason progressive overload works. There's a reason practicing a skill repeatedly makes you better at it. And there's a reason that when you squat consistently, your squat tends to improve.

Do the thing, get better at the thing. Not rocket science.

Our last cycle, LOBO, is a pretty good example. We had clear areas of focus. Heavy deadlifts on Monday, skill development on Tuesday, heavy pressing on Wednesday, and heavy back squats on Friday.

And guess what? People got stronger. A lot stronger. We also saw improvements in gymnastics and skills, including people becoming more comfortable upside down. We consistently exposed ourselves to those movements, progressively increased the demands, and gave our bodies a reason to adapt.

But here's the question that stuck with me from that seminar. If we're putting more marbles into a handful of jars, aren't we taking some out of others?

We weren't front squatting or overhead squatting heavy nearly as often. We weren't regularly working toward heavy jerks. We weren't pulling heavy cleans or snatches from the floor with the same frequency that we were deadlifting.

That doesn't mean LOBO failed. It accomplished exactly what we designed it to accomplish. But every programming decision comes with a trade-off, and the question is whether those trade-offs are appropriate for what we're ultimately trying to develop.

Because a good program isn't necessarily a good program for you.

I could hand you the world's greatest running program, developed by accomplished coaches and proven to produce incredible results. But if your primary goal is to get stronger, it's probably a pretty lousy program for you.

Not because it's poorly designed. It's just not designed to accomplish what you're trying to accomplish. The same goes for the opposite. An incredible powerlifting program probably isn't the best choice for someone whose primary goal is improving their endurance.

And somewhere along the way, I think people started confusing more with better.

A workout with three strength pieces, 15 different movements, a conditioning piece, and enough accessories to keep you in the gym until tomorrow isn't automatically better than a workout with one thoughtfully designed piece.

It just has more shit in it.

More variety doesn't automatically mean better programming. Neither does more volume, more complexity, or how exhausted you feel when you're finished. The quality of a program should be judged by what it's designed to accomplish and how effectively it gets you there.


I Think We Can Do a Little Better

One of my goals with PUSH has always been to elevate the standard and expectations of what we consider general-population fitness.

Just because you're not trying to qualify for the CrossFit Games doesn't mean you shouldn't take your training seriously. It doesn't mean technique stops mattering, nutrition isn't important, or that you shouldn't be working toward something that currently feels out of reach.

I think the whole point of general physical preparedness is that, given enough time and thoughtful training, you should become capable of doing some version of just about anything.

And I genuinely mean that.

Obviously, what that looks like will be different for everyone. Someone's first 5K might represent the same challenge as another person's half marathon. A strict pull-up might be someone's equivalent of another person's muscle-up. Biological age matters. Training age matters. Where you're starting matters.

But the underlying idea doesn't change.

There's a quote commonly attributed to Socrates, recorded in a different form by Xenophon, that essentially says it's a shame for someone to grow old without ever discovering the beauty and strength their body is capable of.

I love that idea.

I want people to maintain some of that kid-like curiosity about movement. Running, jumping, climbing, lifting something heavy, or occasionally looking at a challenge and thinking, "I wonder if I could actually do that."

Sometimes the answer should be, "Fuck it. Let's find out."

That's what I want people to get out of their training. Not just better numbers on a whiteboard, but a broader range of things they're capable of doing outside the gym. The ability to occasionally surprise themselves in a pretty awesome way.

And hopefully come out the other side relatively unscathed.

Of course, developing that kind of fitness takes time. Most people are still building the foundational strength, coordination, endurance, and skills that make those bigger challenges possible.

When someone is brand new to fitness, almost everything works.

Grab someone who's been relatively inactive out of Trader Joe's, preferably with their permission, and introduce them to biking, squatting, pressing, ring rows, and some PVC pipe clean and jerks. Assuming they're training appropriately and consistently, they're probably going to improve at a whole lot of things pretty quickly.

PUSH cartoon coach grabbing new cient at Trader Joe's

They're being absolutely slathered in fitness.

But eventually, we adapt. Progress becomes less predictable, and what once produced noticeable improvements every week might not have the same effect.

That's where thoughtful programming matters. Not necessarily more volume or more intensity, but sometimes, yes.

I'm not against doing ridiculous amounts of work or occasionally pushing yourself into some pretty uncomfortable places. I actually think there's a lot of value in that. Sometimes we need to color outside the lines to know where the lines are.

But there's a difference between challenging yourself and just throwing more shit at a workout. Scaling and modifying aren't reflections of your worth as an athlete. They're tools for finding an appropriate challenge based on where you currently are.

And appropriate doesn't mean easy. At some point, if you want to expand what you're capable of, you have to be willing to push beyond what's currently comfortable.

Sometimes the answer is repeating something, sometimes it's introducing a new challenge, and sometimes it's doing less, but doing it better.

And sometimes it's reconsidering how we're distributing our attention across the different things we're trying to improve. Which brings us to PROTEUS.


So Here's What We're Doing

Proteus is a figure from Greek mythology known for his ability to change form depending on the circumstances. His name eventually gave us the word protean, meaning versatile, adaptable, or capable of taking on many forms.

PUSH cartoon character interacting with Proteus

That's the idea behind this cycle. Not that we're trying to turn everyone into a different person every week, but that our fitness should be capable of expressing itself in different ways.

Instead of Monday always being heavy deadlift day, we might emphasize pulling from the floor. That could mean deadlifts, cleans, snatches, or variations of those movements. Rather than Friday always being heavy back squats, we might see back squats, front squats, overhead squats, or other squat variations.

And just because we're focusing on a particular movement pattern doesn't mean it always needs to live in the same repetition range or time domain.

A deadlift doesn't always have to be five reps or fewer. Maybe we're working toward a heavy triple. Maybe we're doing five sets of 15 at a lighter load. Maybe we're performing moderate deadlifts within a conditioning workout.

Different demands, different adaptations, same fundamental movement pattern.

And that same approach applies to the workouts themselves. We might start the week with a traditional front squat progression, follow it with a classic descending-rep barbell workout, spend another day working through skill development and repeated conditioning intervals, and bring back an old-school CrossFit benchmark like The Seven, with our own little twist.

Some days will look pretty familiar. Others might look a little different from what we've been doing. But the goal isn't to make every workout unique. It's to expose ourselves to a broad enough range of challenges that we're developing more than just a handful of specific abilities.

We'll still squat, hinge, press, pull, carry, run, jump, and practice gymnastics. We'll still train short, medium, and long time domains. We'll still lift heavy.

But rather than consistently tying certain movements to particular days, loads, and repetition schemes, we're going to create more opportunities to challenge those physical qualities in different ways.

We'll also rotate some of those emphases throughout the week. Because if your schedule means you can never come on Wednesdays, you probably shouldn't miss every dedicated pressing session for an entire cycle.

We're not adding variety just for the sake of variety.

If we need to repeat a movement to develop a particular skill or adaptation, we'll repeat it. If the day's goal calls for one heavy lift and nothing else, that's what we'll do. And if a longer conditioning workout is the best way to accomplish what we're after, we don't need to tack on another 20 minutes of work just to make the whiteboard look impressive.

There's still structure, progression, and intention behind what we're doing. We're just distributing the emphasis a little differently.

Ultimately, we're trying to build a foundation broad enough that when a new challenge presents itself, we're already a good part of the way there.


How Do We Know If This Worked?

One thing you'll probably notice is that we won't necessarily have three specific lifts we're working toward retesting at the end of eight weeks.

That doesn't mean we're abandoning measurable progress or that getting stronger is suddenly less important. It means that progress might show up in different ways.

Maybe your legs are getting stronger, even if we haven't spent eight consecutive weeks building toward a back squat PR. Maybe you're becoming more comfortable with Olympic lifts because you're seeing them more frequently. Maybe you're improving your ability to handle different loads, movements, and conditioning demands.

And maybe, somewhere along the way, you find yourself thinking, "Man, this cycle has been fun. And hard. I like that we're doing more of this."

That's valuable feedback, too.

I don't expect everyone to walk into the gym and analyze whether we're appropriately balancing anaerobic capacity training with our strength development. Most people don't know what that means, and frankly, they shouldn't need to. That's my job.

Your job is to show up consistently, pay attention to what we're trying to accomplish, and put in the appropriate effort.

Also, here's something I've noticed over the years that always makes me laugh. Sometimes I think people get more excited about the announcement of a new training cycle than actually doing the cycle itself.

It's like going to the movies, getting up to go to the bathroom every 15 minutes, missing half the movie, and then walking out asking when the sequel is coming out.

PUSH cartoon leaving movie theatre.

You missed half the first one!

I get it. New cycles are exciting. New goals, new challenges, new opportunities to improve. I love that stuff too. I'm the guy who keeps writing and naming them.

But the actual progress happens during the weeks between the announcements. Showing up matters. But what you do while you're here matters even more.


Anyway, Here's the Point

I don't think there's anything wrong with how we've been programming. Quite the opposite. We've seen people get stronger, develop skills, improve their conditioning, and accomplish things they previously thought were out of reach. I'm proud of that.

But I also don't think believing in what you do means you should stop being curious about how to do it better.

What I appreciated about that seminar argument wasn't that it convinced me traditional training cycles were wrong. It simply offered another perspective on how we might approach the same overall goal.

And that goal hasn't changed. We want to develop stronger, fitter, more capable people. People who take their training seriously, challenge themselves, and understand that being physically capable isn't something reserved for competitive athletes.

People who are curious about what they can do, willing to find out, and excited about the possibility that they're capable of more than they think. Not just for the next eight weeks, but for the next eight years, or twenty.

PROTEUS is an opportunity to explore a slightly different way of getting there. I'm excited to see how everyone responds, what we learn, and what we can take from it moving forward.

You all are pretty awesome. And frankly, I'm pretty good at this programming thing.

So with our powers combined, I think we'll be just fine.

Stay Dope.

Comments


bottom of page